3 Comments
User's avatar
Jon Boyd's avatar

"what it means to live in a place or be a part of a community."

I have never read Robert Putnam, but I have read enough discussions of *Bowling Alone* to imagine that considering *communities of place* and contrasting those with *communities of interest*. I have seen two directions in this sort of inquiry.

* NIMBYism replaces communities of place with communities of interest

* NIMBYism is an expression of communities of place, which demonstrates how communities of place can be flawed

I don't recall where I read this. The hive mind must be better read on this than I am, so maybe other commenters might elaborate.

Addison Del Mastro's avatar

Huh, that’s interesting. Have never heard it put that way. I’ve always thought of NIMBYism as being based on the idea that belonging requires exclusion, fellowship requires excommunication, etc. That it’s difficult to imagine a community as existing if it doesn’t impliedly exist against others. Your way is a little more charitable. I also think the way suburbia is designed not to change is part of where this idea comes from.

Jon Boyd's avatar

"Charitable" is a plausible characterization, but my take here is analogous to my take in suburban culture and suburban socialization. Suburbia has communities. Many suburbanites have rich social lives. These are factual claims. Yet I still judge suburbia harshly.

Likewise NIMBYism is consistent with rich social lives and with communities, but I don't think that all communities are beneficial.