Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jon Boyd's avatar

Energy is a necessary but insufficient condition for the long-term prospects of a movement. Our adversary is the Ideology of the Home and we will need to offer a more compelling alternative. We have not achieved that yet. OTOH, the progress is real.

Dustin Pieper's avatar

The tree thing definitely drives me up a wall.

From an environmental standpoint, you need like 400 trees to offset the emissions from just a single car. If you can save just a single car trip a year by cutting down a tree, you're coming out ahead. It's madness.

To say nothing of sprawl. Of course. Or the ability for trees to easily integrate in an urban neighborhood. Or the fact that a small group of trees in the middle of a city don't exactly constitute an ecosystem (especially compared to the real forests outside of town that are being suburbanized).

But your point definitely stands. In a world were development really just means suburbs, it's easy to assume that there is no other way. I think that's our real work to be done.

Same thing with talking to rural folks. The main tricks is two-fold. Focusing on the fact that the government is preventing folks from doing basic simple things with their own land, and also pointing out that good urbanism keeps the city in the city, rather than letting the sprawl invade the countryside. I'm not sure if that will work, but it's better than a lot of tut-tut messaging out there.

Ready for more?