This checks out with my view (recently solidified) that good urbanism is downstream of good government. At the end of the day, every municipality should be funding substantial amounts of transit, even in residents don’t care or don’t want it. You can build all the great buildings you want, without transit, the city is going to fail.
1) to your point -- what are we supposed to do, then, with those who, upon seeing that the levers of power are not bequeathed to them and them alone, proceed to embrace anti-tax/anti-governance ideology (Rand/von Mises ancap thinking, "taxation is theft" brainwormery a la Howard Jarvis, etc) in an effort to become ungovernable? (to the point of suburban boroughitis/jurisdictional balkanization, anti-governance ballot initiatives, and populist revolt)
2) to address the OP, while the "make land use a situation where adding more people makes the party better instead of worse" addresses NIMBYism towards (especially residential) _land development_, how does it address the situation with NIMBYism towards _transportation alternatives_? Is it a sort of Stockholm syndrome induced by car dependency, or downstream of zero-sum/negative-sum thinking where any reallocation of roadspace is seen not as an opportunity to change habits, but purely as an infringement on their turf? (even though the latter hypothesis doesn't explain NIMBYism towards sidewalks, bus service improvements, grade-separated rapid transit, or even mainline rail service expansions)
Creating Parking Benefit Districts would resolve much of this. Charging for parking helps people make the Uber vs Drive trade off. It also incentivizes other businesses to share rather than hoard their parking.
Cities should get rid of both parking minimums and free parking at the same time.
I live in what they call a "streetcar suburb" but the actual trolleys were long ago replaced by buses, and even those might be lost soon due to state funding problems. The buses are absolutely what make this town work. You see a lot of folks taking the bus into the city from here, mostly for commuting, but every additional person on that bus is less traffic trying to get into the busy, colonial-era central business district with streets that were never designed for cars and still don't manage them well even after "urban renewal" and all that. Our most recent township plan allows for apartments over retail along the existing shopping streets and without buses I don't know where those folks are going to be able to park the cars they'll need. We're still not the best laid out town, since half of the town lives on the far side of a 4-to-6-lane highway from the grocery stores, but we can't all be car dependent and be a functional town. We're an inner-ring suburb that was mostly built pre-WWII. We don't have anywhere we can expand to but in or up.
I’m in a very similar boat here! Inner ring burb that was once upon a time accessible via street car that lives on now only in the trail system that we have where the tracks once were. My burb has two major stroads running north-south through it and I have a hard time imagining how we can make it more liveable while these streets segment us. It’s especially unfortunate bc much of the traffic is people passing through our little town on their way to further outlying suburbs. So we carry much of the cost of these stroads (traffic, noise, pollution, few and far between crosswalks) but only part of their benefit (ability to travel out of the area faster).
That's a big one for us. One road is US-1 and that's not going anywhere, but it's actually smaller and calmer than the other East-West stroad that leads out to an interstate and eventually to the turnpike.
Shouldn't restaurants in particular be in transit-accessible locations as much as possible, just in case the diners want something alcoholic with their meal?
When I was a kid growing up in Atlanta I remember my dad freaking out about the potential expansion of MARTA to our city. He had to have spent $20 or $30k lobbying against it. At the time I agreed with him, because I was a kid. Now I wonder what that costs society in the long run?
I don't own a car, and not owning a car was a choice. Like any choice, it comes with some positives and some negatives.
I can't get to national parks as easily, going across town usually takes me 2-3x as long, and costco runs are a challenge. Basically, there are just certain places I can't (easily) get to.
Choosing to own/use a car is also a choice: you can get to that national park easier - but maybe this neighborhood is just functionally off limits to drivers.
As a person that doesn't own a car, I'm used to the idea that getting around can sometimes be complex, or require one-time payments (as opposed to just marginal costs of driving) like renting a car for a weekend. For drivers, that may mean transit (if it exists), e-bike (if they're able) or taxi.
Owning a car isn't a golden ticket to the unfettered freedom of the open road. To assume that a driver coming in from the suburbs should get easy/close/free parking in a place they don't even live is a pretty strong motonormativity bias.
To your last bit, yes of course, but the point is that suburbia as it is physically built implies that bias. My sense is that the vast majority of suburbanite motorists have no conception of having made a *choice* to own a car/drive most places. In fact, this point is something I was going to think about in a follow-up piece. One of the points of contention is that car-free people understand a lot more about getting around and the trade-offs involved than typical motorists do. To the person who feels like easy driving and parking is implied in the place he lives, the urbanists sound like Darth Vader saying "I have altered the deal." Meanwhile they're not upending a deal, there never was a deal, yet the "deal" is dangled in front of us in the form of forcing land use to be car-oriented.
Another solution for dining at a restaurant with limited nearby parking: You phone another couple (or two) and say, “We’ve heard great things about this place, but parking is limited, so can we all go together in one car?” Then you make carpoolers part of the clientele, not just the neighbors who live within walking distance (whose homes you park in front of as the four or six of you arrive together). Needless to say, the designated driver abstains from alcohol.
As you say, it's a bit paradoxical. In a suburb, everything is built around parking, but when it runs out you're just screwed. There's literally nowhere to park. In a city, when the immediate parking gets full, you probably just have to park a little farther away and walk a few blocks.
If the issue is that NIMBYs are correct in suburbia, than you would expect that places that aren't suburban (e.g. Manhattan or San Francisco) would see weaker NIMBYs--that the majority of the population would understand that they didn't need to fear new development, since the fears of loss of parking simply aren't relevant.
But in fact, you see no such trend. Infill development in dense urban areas is often just as hard as infill in suburbia; Manhattan builds at a fairly similar pace to Nassau County (and both of them build less per capita than Austin). There's something else going on that makes a place more amenable or less amenable to infill specifically and development generally.
But this comes back to the same problem as the YIMBY tag - does it mean pure recklessness in overextending development in too dense, infrastructurally-overloaded spaces? Or is it inclusive of people who don’t want to do that but still have a vision of transit and density enriching an already urban district?
I’ve been to a lot of small towns in non-urban counties, and if they want parking mandates in their downtowns, I totally buy into that. It’s not NIMBY, it’s sensible development. NIMBY, to me, is someone who fights building a school or hospital because of some far-fetched idea that such a neighbor would provide appealing benefit to the community *and would impact their real estate resale value or idea of serenity* (usually neither in practice). NIMBY is a very old term and was always targeted to misanthropes, before it started being thrown around in thousands of conversations about intricate situations (e.g. choice between grassy seating area or senior facility + smaller seating area). I don’t think it’s fair to call reasonable people NIMBYs, but there’s an understandable difficulty - actual NIMBYs work overtime to present a veneer of reason
I wouldn't really say they're correct, or at least not blanket correct. Suburbs can easily absorb more housing without traffic becoming unmanageable, and kind of have to absorb new housing for traffic to remain reasonable. If the core city is the only place building apartments, but all the jobs are out in the suburbs now, that's gonna create some pretty awful traffic.
Had these suburbs said "no we don't want jobs here, we're a quiet residential area" I would find NIMBYism more reasonable. But if you have a lot of jobs, you gotta add a bunch of homes. You can't approve a hospital or an office park in your area of the metro and then say no to new homes. The places that are mostly residential with some strip malls and a big box store or two, sure, but that's not most suburbs at this point. Suburbs have been adding jobs for long enough that its no longer really reasonable for them to say no to housing.
Where I do have sympathy for suburban NIMBYs is in the metro areas where urban core cities say no to new housing. Which unfortunately is most of them, or at least most of the older pre war ones. It's hard for me to not feel some level of sympathy for someone being opposed to a big urban development in their suburb when I know if that urban development were proposed in my mostly low rise but fairly urban neighborhood, it would probably bring out even more opposition than it'd get in the suburbs. Over the holidays my uncle (who lives in a suburb of Chicago) was talking about how an apartment was being built near him on some undeveloped land and he got the city council to make it less dense. And on the one hand I'm thinking fuck you. But on the other hand Chicago is incredibly NIMBY and routinely blocks new apartment buildings, even in areas that have apartment buildings. So I do have some sympathy.
I've found myself in thinking about of parking requirements for a different reason. When I lived in Estonia, the older buildings have no off street parking since they were built for people who didn't own cars, so the solution has been to convert sidewalks and greenspace into parking spaces. Areas with newer developments that include underground parking tend to be more pleasant to walk around and don't become car sewers. I know Estonia has minimum parking requirements. I don't know if these garages would be built otherwise, but they do make the city space more pleasant to people without cars.
The most succinct way I've been able to formulate it is:
Most people intuitively grasp the negative-sum nature of most modern development methods, particularly how they're designed to filter money up *not* meet actual people's needs. And it's understandable to think that this is somehow natural or inherent to the system: after all, America was literally founded on an attempt to extract as much unearned wealth from paper claims on land and natural resources, so it's not like we've ever had a system that gets it right. The challenge is both to properly diagnose these issues as artificial and the result of choices made against the broader self interest *and* to propose ways to work to reverse them from within a system where the mistakes have already been made. And it's totally fair to find the existing movements come up short in that (I have given up trying to talk with other housing advocates about why I think Inclusionary Zoning is not actually accomplishing their goals and thus not worth pushing further).
But the purpose of the system is what it does, so at some point you have to accept that the negative outcomes of the Way Things Are can't just be written off as unfortunate: they're active choices that all of us are constantly making and remaking and are fully complicit in, and once you accept that responsibility I think it helps reframe your obligations to pursue *some kind of change* even if there's never going to be a perfect fix.
Great post, Addison. Suburbia doesn't scale, aka the Geometry Problem (link below).
FWIW, I think this can be mitigated in places that have at least a sparse street network, but a large percentage of contemporary development is disconnected and will never be able to adapt to higher density or anything other than driving for every trip.
I suspect that we're going to eventually start building more connected suburbs again, and that over time the sparse and disconnected places bifurcate: the nicest ones will hang on as alternative lifestyle quasi-gated enclaves, while the majority just get dilapidated and gradually abandoned (the same fate that has happened to the earlier generations of streetcar suburbs and early car-suburbs in many of our cities, esp. in the rust belt). But there are probably still a lot of future ruins left to be built before that norm shift occurs.
There is an interesting element of consumer and business choice that comes up in this piece highlighted by this: 'I would say the only reasonable human response to a place that can’t be accessed by transit but which has insufficient parking is “Give me a place to park, damn you!” ' Ultimately when you don't have minimum parking requirements and you leave it to the business owner to provide the parking they think they need based on the intended clientele (basically their business model) - I am fully supportive of this idea everywhere for all uses - there is an implicit statement that if you don't fit the business' assumptions you probably are not the right person to patronize it. To put it more bluntly, just because a potential customer desires to patronize a place (maybe because it's the "hot" place in town) doesn't mean they have a right to drive there. Most businesses that are in favor of no minimum parking requirements and that choose to not provide parking, accept that some people will not be able to access the place. Conversely, any business that expects people to arrive primarily by car and doesn't provide parking and is in a place with little parking in my opinion deserves to fail because they picked the wrong place to locate it; no business should expect that someone else should pay for their parking needs. This is all part of a being a smart business owner. We are having this discussion in Annapolis about a local "nano brewery" that wants to not provide any parking and use their small parking lot full time for patrons. Their position is that they want it to be a neighborhood place where people walk there and they frankly don't care if they miss patrons who have to drive there and can't park when the area is very busy. That's their calculation and they should be allowed to accept the consequences of that decision.
Yes. I guess my inherited suburbanite view is that cars = movement/access, therefore an establishment that isn't accessible by car is existing at the cost of society to cater to a select few (people who can get around without cars or live close). I would never have thought about this as a *view*, let alone a *wrong* view, before I found urbanism. I still *feel* that way but I recognize it isn't correct, nor is it consistent with free enterprise and lowering the barriers to entrepreneurship.
One interesting thing someone else mentioned is having micro-scale businesses that don't generate car traffic, because they just serve very local areas. That's interesting to me - I think suburbia/the car does this thing where you don't have discrete local areas/neighborhoods. If a thing can be reached in a reasonable drive, it's on your map of potential places to visit. So there's a whole different mindset where businesses are at a smaller scale and more localized. The idea of a business theoretically open to the public being effectively only for a local area just sounds very, very weird to me, but I don't see how it doesn't follow from my own ideas!
Also, it's not that it's only available to a local area, rather that it's perhaps only convenient from a local area. You can always drive, you just might have to park far away.
And to put a finer point on it, I don't see why a municipal government should weigh in on who gets to access it or not (ie via minimum parking requirements). I find it ideologically incongruous that people who hate the concept of socialism essentially are promoting it with minimum parking requirements. The argument is always "because then it will cause other parking to get used up", but the answer to that is as Shoup pointed out, municipal governments need to manage their assets properly (ie street parking).
With the restaurant, you're describing an issue between the business and you as a potential customer. For whatever reason, the business decided that location was worth losing some business from people who couldn't find parking. Either they're right or they're wrong and they'll go out of business. In a city does restaurants have 1 hr wait times. I wouldn't wait that long but I don't expect the restaurant to move to a bigger space just to accommodate my desire to eat there.
Well neither would I! Obviously their business assumption will be tested. It's just that I have to fight my impulse to not let it get me angry, and I understand what a mental burden it is to live in a place that you can remember being sparsely populated enough that you could breeze around, and to see it slowly fill up and become frictional. To me that's the genesis of a lot of suburban NIMBYism and as I write the land-use pattern causes it but it also makes sense to feel that way.
This checks out with my view (recently solidified) that good urbanism is downstream of good government. At the end of the day, every municipality should be funding substantial amounts of transit, even in residents don’t care or don’t want it. You can build all the great buildings you want, without transit, the city is going to fail.
1) to your point -- what are we supposed to do, then, with those who, upon seeing that the levers of power are not bequeathed to them and them alone, proceed to embrace anti-tax/anti-governance ideology (Rand/von Mises ancap thinking, "taxation is theft" brainwormery a la Howard Jarvis, etc) in an effort to become ungovernable? (to the point of suburban boroughitis/jurisdictional balkanization, anti-governance ballot initiatives, and populist revolt)
2) to address the OP, while the "make land use a situation where adding more people makes the party better instead of worse" addresses NIMBYism towards (especially residential) _land development_, how does it address the situation with NIMBYism towards _transportation alternatives_? Is it a sort of Stockholm syndrome induced by car dependency, or downstream of zero-sum/negative-sum thinking where any reallocation of roadspace is seen not as an opportunity to change habits, but purely as an infringement on their turf? (even though the latter hypothesis doesn't explain NIMBYism towards sidewalks, bus service improvements, grade-separated rapid transit, or even mainline rail service expansions)
Creating Parking Benefit Districts would resolve much of this. Charging for parking helps people make the Uber vs Drive trade off. It also incentivizes other businesses to share rather than hoard their parking.
Cities should get rid of both parking minimums and free parking at the same time.
100%
I live in what they call a "streetcar suburb" but the actual trolleys were long ago replaced by buses, and even those might be lost soon due to state funding problems. The buses are absolutely what make this town work. You see a lot of folks taking the bus into the city from here, mostly for commuting, but every additional person on that bus is less traffic trying to get into the busy, colonial-era central business district with streets that were never designed for cars and still don't manage them well even after "urban renewal" and all that. Our most recent township plan allows for apartments over retail along the existing shopping streets and without buses I don't know where those folks are going to be able to park the cars they'll need. We're still not the best laid out town, since half of the town lives on the far side of a 4-to-6-lane highway from the grocery stores, but we can't all be car dependent and be a functional town. We're an inner-ring suburb that was mostly built pre-WWII. We don't have anywhere we can expand to but in or up.
I’m in a very similar boat here! Inner ring burb that was once upon a time accessible via street car that lives on now only in the trail system that we have where the tracks once were. My burb has two major stroads running north-south through it and I have a hard time imagining how we can make it more liveable while these streets segment us. It’s especially unfortunate bc much of the traffic is people passing through our little town on their way to further outlying suburbs. So we carry much of the cost of these stroads (traffic, noise, pollution, few and far between crosswalks) but only part of their benefit (ability to travel out of the area faster).
That's a big one for us. One road is US-1 and that's not going anywhere, but it's actually smaller and calmer than the other East-West stroad that leads out to an interstate and eventually to the turnpike.
Shouldn't restaurants in particular be in transit-accessible locations as much as possible, just in case the diners want something alcoholic with their meal?
When I was a kid growing up in Atlanta I remember my dad freaking out about the potential expansion of MARTA to our city. He had to have spent $20 or $30k lobbying against it. At the time I agreed with him, because I was a kid. Now I wonder what that costs society in the long run?
Thanks for sharing!
I don't own a car, and not owning a car was a choice. Like any choice, it comes with some positives and some negatives.
I can't get to national parks as easily, going across town usually takes me 2-3x as long, and costco runs are a challenge. Basically, there are just certain places I can't (easily) get to.
Choosing to own/use a car is also a choice: you can get to that national park easier - but maybe this neighborhood is just functionally off limits to drivers.
As a person that doesn't own a car, I'm used to the idea that getting around can sometimes be complex, or require one-time payments (as opposed to just marginal costs of driving) like renting a car for a weekend. For drivers, that may mean transit (if it exists), e-bike (if they're able) or taxi.
Owning a car isn't a golden ticket to the unfettered freedom of the open road. To assume that a driver coming in from the suburbs should get easy/close/free parking in a place they don't even live is a pretty strong motonormativity bias.
To your last bit, yes of course, but the point is that suburbia as it is physically built implies that bias. My sense is that the vast majority of suburbanite motorists have no conception of having made a *choice* to own a car/drive most places. In fact, this point is something I was going to think about in a follow-up piece. One of the points of contention is that car-free people understand a lot more about getting around and the trade-offs involved than typical motorists do. To the person who feels like easy driving and parking is implied in the place he lives, the urbanists sound like Darth Vader saying "I have altered the deal." Meanwhile they're not upending a deal, there never was a deal, yet the "deal" is dangled in front of us in the form of forcing land use to be car-oriented.
Another solution for dining at a restaurant with limited nearby parking: You phone another couple (or two) and say, “We’ve heard great things about this place, but parking is limited, so can we all go together in one car?” Then you make carpoolers part of the clientele, not just the neighbors who live within walking distance (whose homes you park in front of as the four or six of you arrive together). Needless to say, the designated driver abstains from alcohol.
As you say, it's a bit paradoxical. In a suburb, everything is built around parking, but when it runs out you're just screwed. There's literally nowhere to park. In a city, when the immediate parking gets full, you probably just have to park a little farther away and walk a few blocks.
If the issue is that NIMBYs are correct in suburbia, than you would expect that places that aren't suburban (e.g. Manhattan or San Francisco) would see weaker NIMBYs--that the majority of the population would understand that they didn't need to fear new development, since the fears of loss of parking simply aren't relevant.
But in fact, you see no such trend. Infill development in dense urban areas is often just as hard as infill in suburbia; Manhattan builds at a fairly similar pace to Nassau County (and both of them build less per capita than Austin). There's something else going on that makes a place more amenable or less amenable to infill specifically and development generally.
But this comes back to the same problem as the YIMBY tag - does it mean pure recklessness in overextending development in too dense, infrastructurally-overloaded spaces? Or is it inclusive of people who don’t want to do that but still have a vision of transit and density enriching an already urban district?
I’ve been to a lot of small towns in non-urban counties, and if they want parking mandates in their downtowns, I totally buy into that. It’s not NIMBY, it’s sensible development. NIMBY, to me, is someone who fights building a school or hospital because of some far-fetched idea that such a neighbor would provide appealing benefit to the community *and would impact their real estate resale value or idea of serenity* (usually neither in practice). NIMBY is a very old term and was always targeted to misanthropes, before it started being thrown around in thousands of conversations about intricate situations (e.g. choice between grassy seating area or senior facility + smaller seating area). I don’t think it’s fair to call reasonable people NIMBYs, but there’s an understandable difficulty - actual NIMBYs work overtime to present a veneer of reason
I wouldn't really say they're correct, or at least not blanket correct. Suburbs can easily absorb more housing without traffic becoming unmanageable, and kind of have to absorb new housing for traffic to remain reasonable. If the core city is the only place building apartments, but all the jobs are out in the suburbs now, that's gonna create some pretty awful traffic.
Had these suburbs said "no we don't want jobs here, we're a quiet residential area" I would find NIMBYism more reasonable. But if you have a lot of jobs, you gotta add a bunch of homes. You can't approve a hospital or an office park in your area of the metro and then say no to new homes. The places that are mostly residential with some strip malls and a big box store or two, sure, but that's not most suburbs at this point. Suburbs have been adding jobs for long enough that its no longer really reasonable for them to say no to housing.
Where I do have sympathy for suburban NIMBYs is in the metro areas where urban core cities say no to new housing. Which unfortunately is most of them, or at least most of the older pre war ones. It's hard for me to not feel some level of sympathy for someone being opposed to a big urban development in their suburb when I know if that urban development were proposed in my mostly low rise but fairly urban neighborhood, it would probably bring out even more opposition than it'd get in the suburbs. Over the holidays my uncle (who lives in a suburb of Chicago) was talking about how an apartment was being built near him on some undeveloped land and he got the city council to make it less dense. And on the one hand I'm thinking fuck you. But on the other hand Chicago is incredibly NIMBY and routinely blocks new apartment buildings, even in areas that have apartment buildings. So I do have some sympathy.
I've found myself in thinking about of parking requirements for a different reason. When I lived in Estonia, the older buildings have no off street parking since they were built for people who didn't own cars, so the solution has been to convert sidewalks and greenspace into parking spaces. Areas with newer developments that include underground parking tend to be more pleasant to walk around and don't become car sewers. I know Estonia has minimum parking requirements. I don't know if these garages would be built otherwise, but they do make the city space more pleasant to people without cars.
The most succinct way I've been able to formulate it is:
Most people intuitively grasp the negative-sum nature of most modern development methods, particularly how they're designed to filter money up *not* meet actual people's needs. And it's understandable to think that this is somehow natural or inherent to the system: after all, America was literally founded on an attempt to extract as much unearned wealth from paper claims on land and natural resources, so it's not like we've ever had a system that gets it right. The challenge is both to properly diagnose these issues as artificial and the result of choices made against the broader self interest *and* to propose ways to work to reverse them from within a system where the mistakes have already been made. And it's totally fair to find the existing movements come up short in that (I have given up trying to talk with other housing advocates about why I think Inclusionary Zoning is not actually accomplishing their goals and thus not worth pushing further).
But the purpose of the system is what it does, so at some point you have to accept that the negative outcomes of the Way Things Are can't just be written off as unfortunate: they're active choices that all of us are constantly making and remaking and are fully complicit in, and once you accept that responsibility I think it helps reframe your obligations to pursue *some kind of change* even if there's never going to be a perfect fix.
Aside from a Land Value Tax, of course ;)
Great post, Addison. Suburbia doesn't scale, aka the Geometry Problem (link below).
FWIW, I think this can be mitigated in places that have at least a sparse street network, but a large percentage of contemporary development is disconnected and will never be able to adapt to higher density or anything other than driving for every trip.
I suspect that we're going to eventually start building more connected suburbs again, and that over time the sparse and disconnected places bifurcate: the nicest ones will hang on as alternative lifestyle quasi-gated enclaves, while the majority just get dilapidated and gradually abandoned (the same fate that has happened to the earlier generations of streetcar suburbs and early car-suburbs in many of our cities, esp. in the rust belt). But there are probably still a lot of future ruins left to be built before that norm shift occurs.
https://postsuburban.substack.com/p/the-geometry-problem
There is an interesting element of consumer and business choice that comes up in this piece highlighted by this: 'I would say the only reasonable human response to a place that can’t be accessed by transit but which has insufficient parking is “Give me a place to park, damn you!” ' Ultimately when you don't have minimum parking requirements and you leave it to the business owner to provide the parking they think they need based on the intended clientele (basically their business model) - I am fully supportive of this idea everywhere for all uses - there is an implicit statement that if you don't fit the business' assumptions you probably are not the right person to patronize it. To put it more bluntly, just because a potential customer desires to patronize a place (maybe because it's the "hot" place in town) doesn't mean they have a right to drive there. Most businesses that are in favor of no minimum parking requirements and that choose to not provide parking, accept that some people will not be able to access the place. Conversely, any business that expects people to arrive primarily by car and doesn't provide parking and is in a place with little parking in my opinion deserves to fail because they picked the wrong place to locate it; no business should expect that someone else should pay for their parking needs. This is all part of a being a smart business owner. We are having this discussion in Annapolis about a local "nano brewery" that wants to not provide any parking and use their small parking lot full time for patrons. Their position is that they want it to be a neighborhood place where people walk there and they frankly don't care if they miss patrons who have to drive there and can't park when the area is very busy. That's their calculation and they should be allowed to accept the consequences of that decision.
Yes. I guess my inherited suburbanite view is that cars = movement/access, therefore an establishment that isn't accessible by car is existing at the cost of society to cater to a select few (people who can get around without cars or live close). I would never have thought about this as a *view*, let alone a *wrong* view, before I found urbanism. I still *feel* that way but I recognize it isn't correct, nor is it consistent with free enterprise and lowering the barriers to entrepreneurship.
One interesting thing someone else mentioned is having micro-scale businesses that don't generate car traffic, because they just serve very local areas. That's interesting to me - I think suburbia/the car does this thing where you don't have discrete local areas/neighborhoods. If a thing can be reached in a reasonable drive, it's on your map of potential places to visit. So there's a whole different mindset where businesses are at a smaller scale and more localized. The idea of a business theoretically open to the public being effectively only for a local area just sounds very, very weird to me, but I don't see how it doesn't follow from my own ideas!
Also, it's not that it's only available to a local area, rather that it's perhaps only convenient from a local area. You can always drive, you just might have to park far away.
And to put a finer point on it, I don't see why a municipal government should weigh in on who gets to access it or not (ie via minimum parking requirements). I find it ideologically incongruous that people who hate the concept of socialism essentially are promoting it with minimum parking requirements. The argument is always "because then it will cause other parking to get used up", but the answer to that is as Shoup pointed out, municipal governments need to manage their assets properly (ie street parking).
With the restaurant, you're describing an issue between the business and you as a potential customer. For whatever reason, the business decided that location was worth losing some business from people who couldn't find parking. Either they're right or they're wrong and they'll go out of business. In a city does restaurants have 1 hr wait times. I wouldn't wait that long but I don't expect the restaurant to move to a bigger space just to accommodate my desire to eat there.
Well neither would I! Obviously their business assumption will be tested. It's just that I have to fight my impulse to not let it get me angry, and I understand what a mental burden it is to live in a place that you can remember being sparsely populated enough that you could breeze around, and to see it slowly fill up and become frictional. To me that's the genesis of a lot of suburban NIMBYism and as I write the land-use pattern causes it but it also makes sense to feel that way.