I’ve written about this phenomenon from time to time of YIMBY/housing advocacy not really being a movement or interest-group thing, but rather a basic, pre-political idea that our weird politics has forced to manifest itself in the form of a political interest group.
In writing about cities and crime recently, I had a thought related to this. It occurred to me while I was working on this bit:
The tough-on-crime folks who talk about “cleaning up” cities do not always appear to really want cities to be clean, safe, and nice. They seem sometimes to want to “clean up” cities in the sense that DOGE rendered the federal government efficient. That is, they view themselves as engaged in a battle, and their passion is not coming from a place of love or care. Nor do they like or respect the experience of urbanites who feel safe, despite elevated crime rates.
Upon being told that it is, in fact, generally safe to walk down the street or ride the subway, the response is rarely “Well, that’s great, although you know it could probably be safer still, so we shouldn’t neglect fighting crime.”
Rather, the concern shifts suddenly to contempt: something like, Okay then, learn the hard way. For people who worry about crime too much, their fear is more real to them than the absence of the thing they fear. The experience of people who have not been victimized by crime doesn’t “count”—they were lucky, or they’re naive, or they’re future victims.
A lot of advocates/activists, I thought, seem like this: like they secretly like the idea of their pet problem being an ongoing catastrophe. Like they find validation and purpose not in its solution, but in its existence. Some of this is probably “March of Dimes syndrome,” where organizational incentives point towards continuing to exist rather than solving the problem for which you exist (when March of Dimes “won” with the eradication of polio, it chose a new and much more open-ended mission of fighting for infant and maternal health, which couldn’t ever be neatly “solved”).
Or think about environmentalists who scoff at fusion power or technological innovation. Yes, what they’ll say is “That will never happen,” or “That will never be economical,” or “A world of dwindling resources isn’t going to be stable or affluent enough for one or two big technical breakthroughs to make the difference.” Maybe.
But one detects a certain disappointment at the idea that the world might not be ending; that after all the anxiety, excitement, and expectation, we might just muddle on through.
A great deal of activism feels like this: a kind of secret cheering for the problem to continue or even get worse, or a suppressed glee that things really might be that bad.
All of this is to make the point that I never detect this dynamic with YIMBYs or housing folks. All of them, in my experience, actually want their problem to be solved. They would be happy to hang up their housing-advocacy hats and simply live in a political environment in which the need to build enough housing is simply as obvious as the need to grow and produce enough food. They are not invested in the housing shortage as their raison d’être.
I don’t find housing folks to typically seem bitter or resentful. They’re clear-eyed about how bad things are, and yes, there’s trash-talking of NIMBYs. But they mostly just seem like regular people who realized we’ve gotten something very simple very wrong. There’s a sense of joy and expectation for this getting better—a positive vision of what our society would look like if the problem were solved. Most of the folks I know emphasize this result or future more than the problem.
I think this is part of why YIMBY broke through as a phenomenon, instead of being a narrow regional or political thing. I’ve watched, just in the few years I’ve been following these issues, as “housing” has steadily become a more and more mainstream, bipartisan concern. The obvious investment in the solution, the practical approach to building coalitions, and the broad appeal of the message, don’t just tell me that these folks are canny and good at what they do. It’s evidence, to me, that the message and goal is true. That underlying what looks like just another of many causes is something really essential and universal.
What do you think?
Related Reading:
“Give Me a House,” Says Almost No One
Thank you for reading! Please consider upgrading to a paid subscription to help support this newsletter. You’ll get a weekly subscribers-only piece, plus full access to the archive: over 1,300 pieces and growing. And you’ll help ensure more like this!


I'd definitely say most in the YIMBY umbrella have a Cincinnatus attitude. Even the most "pie in the sky" goals, vision zero, are celebrated where they happen (such as Hoboken NJ) rather than ignored as insignificant.
This is definitely a problem in addressing homelessness. For some activists, dysfunctional homeless encampments are an end in themselves; they justify continued advocacy and provide a point of criticism to the civil servants actually working on finding long term housing, institutions, and sobriety programs for homeless individuals.