A new restaurant that I’m interested in opened up recently, and for some reason it has a very small parking lot (I don’t know if it predates a parking requirement, or if it got an exception).
In a couple of reviews, people mention maybe parking at the strip plaza a few hundred feet away and crossing the street, which is a fairly wide “stroad.” Neither safe nor technically allowed (parking and walking off is not allowed, that is). This has me thinking about the question of repealing parking requirements, a popular cause among urbanists and one that I’ve written about before. I’m in favor of this—parking will still be built in places where it’s needed, developers often know how much parking they’re likely to need more so than governments, parking requirements raise the barriers to entry for small businesses, etc.
But for all that, I’m a suburbanite, and most of those concerns are abstract for me/in my experience, whereas I very much get the frustration of not being able to find a parking spot when I want to go somewhere. There’s something intensely, almost primally frustrating about seeing people getting to enjoy something that feels gated off for you.
My intellectual belief that parking mandates are a wasteful interference in private property rights withers when I see a restaurant or other destination that feels inaccessible. It feels parasitical, a place that benefits from public infrastructure and road access but doesn’t provide space for customers. Why should they have the right to tantalize you like that? How are you supposed to get there?
You could stop there—which is where a lot of Americans stop. And you could just oppose getting rid of the parking requirements, oppose zoning changes that would make places denser (and more traffic-choked with fewer parking spots to go around)>
Or you could notice that one of the issues is that this restaurant is barely transit-accessible (I suppose you could work out a bus trip that would get you there, but it would take a long time and involve transfers). So it feels like you’re being told, “You have to drive to get here, but you can’t park your car anywhere.”
For me, the first part is the problem, not the second. This means two things. One is that we should make it easier to get around without a car. Two, in the absence of that, NIMBYism is completely logical and reasonable.
I would say the only reasonable human response to a place that can’t be accessed by transit but which has insufficient parking is “Give me a place to park, damn you!” I simultaneously think suburban NIMBYism makes sense, and want to change the circumstances which make it make sense. NIMBYism is the operating principle of car-oriented suburbia. It naturally follows from this pattern of land use and transportation.
YIMBYs often laugh at/sneer at NIMBYs, which in many cases is warranted. But I don’t think all NIMBYism is the same. Even Manhattan has people who complain about tall buildings; that’s insane. But people who live in pretty spread-out, car-dependent places skeptical of adding density? That makes a lot more sense because it very well might degrade your everyday quality of life. In other words, I don’t think all NIMBYism simply reduces to misanthropy (or worse).
This is one of the reasons I’ve always liked Strong Towns so much. Their work spoke, and speaks, to me as a suburbanite who had to be convinced of urbanism. One article in particular informed the way I think about this question of when NIMBYism makes sense, and I want to credit it here. It’s called “The Party Analogy” and it basically argues that traditional urban places get better with density, while post-car/post-zoning suburbs get worse:
More people simply means more traffic congestion. More people at the park. Longer lines at the library. It means that the green space I enjoyed driving by will be turned into homes and strip malls. In some places, it means neighborhoods becoming more expensive and long-term residents being pushed out.
I sometimes get from urbanists/YIMBYs a feeling that they don’t think this is true, or don’t want to acknowledge it, or want to dismiss it as a selfish, politically illegitimate feeling. I agree in that you manifestly can’t base housing policy on what current homeowners want. You simply can’t, because that’s how we got here. But part of the why is that it’s hard to densify suburbs, which is where most of us live nowadays.
So the long-term answer isn’t to browbeat or guilt people into accepting more people. It’s to get the principles of land use and urban design right, so that more people are not a hot potato somebody has to get left holding, but instead a resource. The shame is not that selfish NIMBYs block progress, but that modern suburban pattern turns people into a liability.
Related Reading:
Modern Suburbia Turns Being Fully Human Into A Luxury
That Damned Elusive Parking Spot
Thank you for reading! Please consider upgrading to a paid subscription to help support this newsletter. You’ll get a weekly subscribers-only piece, plus full access to the archive: over 1,300 pieces and growing. And you’ll help ensure more like this!


This checks out with my view (recently solidified) that good urbanism is downstream of good government. At the end of the day, every municipality should be funding substantial amounts of transit, even in residents don’t care or don’t want it. You can build all the great buildings you want, without transit, the city is going to fail.
Creating Parking Benefit Districts would resolve much of this. Charging for parking helps people make the Uber vs Drive trade off. It also incentivizes other businesses to share rather than hoard their parking.
Cities should get rid of both parking minimums and free parking at the same time.