I’m flying to the YIMBYtown conference in Raleigh, North Carolina today. This seemed like a fitting piece from my archives to republish. A version of this piece originally ran in November 2025.
One of the points of disagreement that I’ve sensed between YIMBYs and housing advocates in general on the one hand, and regular people with NIMBYish feeling on the other, is what it means to live in a place or be a part of a community.
If you follow, say, local Facebook pages, there will often be posts about new housing developments, and the comments in my experience tend to lean pretty heavily negative. What’s interesting to me, though, is not that people don’t want their communities to change—which is a normal sentiment, if an unrealistic one—but how they specifically present that opinion.
Sometimes it’s just “Ugh more development, I don’t like that.” But quite often it’s more along the lines of “Who is this for?” or “Nobody wants this!” or “They’re turning our quiet little town into [big city or slightly larger small town nearby].”
Whether it’s greedy developers or corrupt politicians or illegal immigrants or entitled Millennials or your bogeyman of choice, some “they” is responsible for foisting over-development on a happy community that doesn’t want it.
In the NIMBY view, development is a thing that is done to communities collectively, not a thing that is fundamentally part of what it means to be a community. Instead, community membership or neighborliness implies defending the community against outsiders, as though favoring new housing is an illegitimate opinion.
In this view, choosing to live in a specific place implies that you have agreed to a sort of contract to fight to keep the place as it is. Being a housing advocate, in short, makes you a bad neighbor, a traitor, someone who selfishly chose a community not to your liking and now seeks to impose your own preferences on everyone else. Even if you live there, you’re “they.”
This conception of what it means to be part of a community is zero-sum. It treats neighbors not as people, but as fixed entities. It treats communities as consumer products, not as dynamic, living things. Most of all, it fails to count “I live in this town and I am in favor of this new housing” as a valid answer. The idea that “nobody wants this” becomes circular. Anybody who wants it isn’t really part of the community. You aren’t proving that some members do want it; you’re just proving that you’re one of those nefarious “they.”
This notion of neighborliness and community is akin to basing fellowship on excommunication.
Trying to translate these normal human feelings of change aversion, familiarity, and nostalgia into housing policy is how we got the housing crisis. But nonetheless they are normal human feelings.
I suspect that most people have never really thought through these things very much. I’m sympathetic to the anti-development impulse because I think it’s pretty much the default or inherited view in America. Before I got interested in housing and urban issues, I subscribed, more or less by osmosis, to the NIMBY side.
Who the hell wants more traffic and construction noise and crowding? What kind of lunatic wants more neighbors? It would not have occurred to me that there was an actual other side to this question that wasn’t a conscious attempt to ruin nice places. I would have assumed that “housing advocacy” was some kind of Trojan horse for greedy developers or corrupt politicians. What other explanation could there be?
Growing up and having to find a place to live disabused me of that, but so did learning about these issues and hearing directly from people involved in housing—regular people who favor new housing in their own communities, and not as an abstraction or a thing that always belongs “somewhere else.”
You might also like:


"what it means to live in a place or be a part of a community."
I have never read Robert Putnam, but I have read enough discussions of *Bowling Alone* to imagine that considering *communities of place* and contrasting those with *communities of interest*. I have seen two directions in this sort of inquiry.
* NIMBYism replaces communities of place with communities of interest
* NIMBYism is an expression of communities of place, which demonstrates how communities of place can be flawed
I don't recall where I read this. The hive mind must be better read on this than I am, so maybe other commenters might elaborate.